Stuffed shells are a favorite in my home! I mean who doesn’t love a good cheesy, baked, saucy pasta dish?! I make these so many different ways so I encourage you to have some fun with them! I had been craving some tikka masala so I made this quick version of a tikka masala cream sauce rather than a basic white sauce and it turned out amazing! I had SO many veggies in the fridge so instead of using chicken or ground turkey like I normally do in my stuffed shells, I packed the shells filled with zucchini, mushrooms, corn and peppers! You could seriously use any vegetable in this dish and it would taste great! I like to use mushrooms because they have a meatier texture that holds well in the shell, and zucchini for its juiciness! My husband is not a fan of mushrooms or zucchini, but he tore these shells UP! lol. I could imagine it to be a great way to sneak some veggies into your kids meals if they are picky eaters.
I made a big tray of these, served it with a side of garlic bread and had enough sauce left over so we all spooned it on top of the shells after they came out of the oven and used the bread to soak up the extra sauce! SO DELICIOUS!
These shells are also great option to take for a pot luck dinner as you can prep the entire tray ahead of time and then just pop it in the oven when you get to your destination! It is something the old and the young can both indulge in! I hope you enjoy this recipe and if you do make it, be sure to tag my instagram handle @thechutneylife.
Happy Eating!!








Enjoyed this dish and will definitely be making it again! ?
Hello! Congratulations Palak on your handsome baby boy. I’ve made these stuffed shells a few times now without fail. I change up the vegetables depending on what I need to use up and it turns out perfect every time. This is one of our favorite fusion dishes in the Patel household thanks to you Palak!
How many days in advance can you make the sauce/mix? I plan to assemble and bake the day I’m serving it, but would love to prep most of it in advance if possible.
Hey the sauce will be fine two days ahead- same as the filling ! THen like you said, just assemble the day of!
Hi! This looks so delish.. will be making it for thanksgiving this year! if I am cooking for 10-12 people how would I adjust the recipe? Let me know. Thanks! and congrats on the baby!
This is a great recipe!
Can we replace the chicken broth? Can it be water or has to be veggie broth? Also if I want to do it with paneer, do you have any suggestions?
Hey Priya!
You can definitely use water, however the vegetable broth just adds another layer of flavor. You can add shredded paneer into the mix of the vegetables when sautéing! Many people have added paneer this way 🙂
Sooooo good! Made this for my entire family and everyone devoured it – lots of flavour!
Manpreet, so glad your family loved this recipe!! Its great for a crowd 🙂
Hi there, this looks good!
Can we do without the Star anise and 1 black cardamom .. is it a must.. would this significantly change the taste ??
Hey! You can omit those and it won’t significantly affect the taste 🙂
Do the shells need to be cooked before going in the oven?
The shells should be cooked
Yummy!!! Thanks !
This was amazing! I hated stuffed shells growing up and this is the total opposite reaction I had while eating this today. Thank you for posting and creating this delicious recipe!
so great to hear!! thank you!!
I don’t have tandoori Masala, what would you use as an alternate?
Hey, there isn’t really a substitute for that, it imparts a lot of flavor and color so definitely try it once you get some tandoori masala!